Leaving a legacy behind is never easy, especially when it’s with a team that’s been your second family. But here’s where it gets emotional: Manly Sea Eagles star Reuben Garrick has finally opened up about the heart-wrenching decision to leave the club after seven seasons, calling it the ‘hardest part’ of his career. And this is the part most people miss—it’s not just about the contract; it’s about loyalty, friendships, and the weight of saying goodbye.
Since bursting onto the scene in 2019, Garrick has been a cornerstone of the Sea Eagles’ back-line, racking up over 150 appearances and solidifying his status as one of the team’s most dependable players. Yet, in a move that shocked fans and teammates alike, the 28-year-old announced in November that he would be joining the Sydney Roosters, following in the footsteps of former teammates Daly Cherry-Evans and Tommy Talau. But here’s where it gets controversial: Was this a step toward personal growth, or a betrayal of the club that gave him his start? Garrick’s decision to sign a three-year deal with the Roosters until 2029 has sparked debates among fans, with some questioning his loyalty and others applauding his ambition.
In a candid interview on Backstage with Cooper & Matty Johns, Garrick didn’t hold back. ‘It was bloody tough,’ he admitted, reflecting on his eight-year journey with Manly. ‘They gave me my shot, and I’ve made lifelong friends there. Leaving wasn’t just about me—it was about telling the boys, the people I’ve trusted and played alongside for years. That was the hardest part.’ And this is the part most people miss: Despite Manly reportedly offering him a deal worth over $1 million, Garrick felt the need to explore a new system, to grow and learn in a different environment. ‘I just want to challenge myself,’ he explained. ‘I think it’s the best thing for my career.’
Interestingly, Garrick confirmed he won’t be pushing for an early release to join the Roosters before 2027, emphasizing his honesty throughout the process. ‘I was upfront with Seibs and the Manly ownership,’ he said. ‘I told them I wouldn’t hide anything. As soon as I knew, they knew.’
But here’s where it gets controversial: Was Garrick’s move a calculated career step or a missed opportunity for Manly to retain a key player? And what does this say about player loyalty in modern sports? The St George Illawarra Dragons were also rumored to be interested in Garrick, Manly’s third all-time point scorer, adding another layer to this complex narrative.
As Garrick prepares for his new chapter, one thing is clear: his decision has left fans and critics alike divided. What do you think? Was this the right move for Garrick, or should he have stayed loyal to the club that shaped him? Let us know in the comments—this is one debate that’s far from over.
